Skip to content
Dairy HavenGet Directions
Dairy Haven’s illuminated cow sign, red neon roofline, and blue-striped awning at dusk

Caseyville, IL

Homemade orange
sherbert

Cones, sundaes, shakes, and the homemade orange sherbert Caseyville knows by heart.

View the menu Get directions
A local favorite since 1954
A tall chocolate and vanilla twist cone held outside Dairy Haven
A child enjoying a sprinkle-covered cup of ice cream at Dairy Haven
Open daily · 9–12Cash onlySeason ends October 11th112 N Main St · Caseyville, ILFeatured onFOX 2 now

Our specialties

View full menu
Five sizes of Dairy Haven’s homemade orange sherbert and vanilla twist cones lined up on the counterThe hometown favorite

Famous for our

Homemade
orange sherbert.

A chocolate and vanilla twist cone in front of Dairy Haven’s blue service counter

The classic twist

Dairy Haven soft serve covered in berry topping, served in a green cup

Sundae kind of day

A thick Dairy Haven concrete in a blue-patterned paper cup

Make it a concrete

A Dairy Haven Royal Brownie sundae with soft serve, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry

Royal brownie

Baby
$1.45
Small
$2.20
Medium
$2.85
Large
$3.25
Jumbo
$4.55
Sugar
$2.55
Waffle
$4.00
Dipped
$3.00 / $3.65
Small / medium

Flavor burst 80¢ extra · Quart $8.35

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Orange
  • Strawberry
  • Orange/Vanilla Twist
  • Chocolate/Vanilla Twist
  • Strawberry/Vanilla Twist
Pint
$4.55
Quart
$8.35
  • Vanilla
  • Orange
  • Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Orange Twist
  • Chocolate Twist
  • Strawberry Twist
Baby
$2.55
Small
$3.20
Medium
$3.80
Large
$4.80
Jumbo pint
$7.15
Sugar
$3.65
Waffle
$5.45
Quart
$13.00
Cash onlyUpdated September 2026
An older photograph of Dairy Haven’s white stand and blue-striped awning, with customers at the window
The little standCaseyville, IL
Dairy Haven’s white stand and blue-striped awning today
Still the same spot
Serving Caseyville since 1954

Serving Caseyville
for generations

For generations, Dairy Haven has been part of life in Caseyville. Opening day remains a long-loved tradition, bringing families, friends, and familiar faces back to Main Street each season.

Since 1954, the stand has stayed rooted in the things that made it part of the community: homemade orange sherbert, familiar faces at the window, and a simple place to gather. That history and care still shape Dairy Haven today.

Good things get around

This has been one of my favorite places to go get ice cream with my family since I was a kid.
Amanda ORead on Tripadvisor
From my childhood right up to this very moment, this ice-cream shop has remained the same; excellent.
madshaolinRead on MenuPix

Come get
some!

Bring your people. Pick your favorite.
We’ll take care of the sweet part.

Get directions

Dairy Haven

112 N Main St
Caseyville, IL 62232

Making a trip?

Open every day from 9–12.

Give us a ring

(618) 345-8866